Wednesday, April 19, 2006

FIRE Update: April 19, 2006

Table of Contents
 
1.
‘USA Today’ on FIRE and the Mohammed Cartoons
2.
Recent Media Coverage
3.
Recent Posts to The Torch
4.
Upcoming Events
‘USA TODAY’ ON FIRE AND THE MOHAMMED CARTOONS

USA Today this morning features a piece by Nat Hentoff, noted columnist and member of FIRE’s Board of Advisors, discussing the Danish Mohammed cartoon controversy on America’s campuses. In the article, “‘Free speech’ cries ring hollow on college campuses and beyond,” Hentoff focuses on shameful instances of censorship at Minnesota’s Century College and at New York University—both cases in which FIRE was involved. The column is particularly timely in light of FIRE’s letter to NYU yesterday asking President John Sexton to publicly repudiate the university’s censorship of a discussion about the cartoons and to live up to the university’s promises of freedom of expression.

RECENT MEDIA COVERAGE

USA Today, April 19, "'Free speech' cries ring hollow on college campuses and beyond," by Nat Hentoff

Century College's administration — and indeed, all who wither amid such free speech controversies — should welcome a challenge from Oliver Wendell Holmes: "If there is any principle of the Constitution that more imperatively calls for attachment than any other, it is the principle of free thought — not free thought for those who agree with us, but freedom for the thought that we hate."

·    ·    ·

National Review, April 18, "Tools for School," by Anthony Dick

Although the authors do not attempt to provide a comprehensive program geared toward fighting the problem they identify, the Guide itself is an important part of that program. Silverglate and Lorence paint a clear and convincing portrait of the types of coercive indoctrination that are currently flourishing in our institutions of higher learning. In so doing, they arm students with an array of moral and legal arguments to fight back against those who seek to convert the academy into a tool for political conversion.

·    ·    ·

The Appalachian (Appalachian State Univ.), April 13, "ACLU works toward harrassment policy change," by Nick Ianniello

FIRE has updated its national student rights Web site, “Spotlight: the Campus Freedom Resource,” to reflect the university’s changes, but Appalachian is still a “red light” school.

·    ·    ·

The Villager (New York), April 12, "N.Y.U. bans Danish cartoons’ display at campus talk," by Chad Smith

“N.Y.U. is a university. A university is a place for free and unfettered discussion in the pursuit if knowledge,” said Jonathan Leaf, a speaker at Wednesday night’s event. Leaf, a former editor at New York Press, resigned from his post at the newspaper after its owners denied the editorial staff the right to reprint the Danish cartoons.

·    ·    ·

The Daily Reveille (Louisiana State Univ.), April 6, "Speech codes choke off discourse, satire," by Jason Doré

The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education currently gives LSU’s speech code a rating of red. According to the FIRE Web site, a red-light university has at least one policy that both clearly and substantially restricts freedom of speech. The University’s harassment policies are singled out as a threat to speech on the FIRE rating Web site.

·    ·    ·

The Spectator (Univ. of Wisconsin–Eau Claire), April 6, "National Library Week celebrated," by Adrian Northrup

Syverson chose "FIRE's Guide to Free Speech on Campus" as the book he was photographed with. The book, which discusses freedom of speech and how the modern university should be a marketplace of ideas, is very different than some of the other selections, Syverson said.

·    ·    ·

The Crimson White (Univ. of Alabama), April 5, "Resolution wrong way to fight against bias," by Patrick Samples

Of course, the notion that the exercise of free speech could be considered a federal crime is patently absurd. The issue here is that the attempt to regulate the press or the expression of opinions by individual students is wrong. And it is wrong whether liberals do it or conservatives do it.

·    ·    ·

Cybercast News Service, April 3, "NYU on Mohammed Cartoons: Discuss, but Don't Look," by Nathan Burchfiel

But Greg Lukianoff, president of the free speech advocacy group Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, said the decision to ban the cartoons was wrong. The university's position that students could discuss the cartoons without seeing them was "one of the most frustrating and asinine arguments that I've heard," Lukianoff said.

·    ·    ·

Washington Square News (New York Univ.), April 3, "Admin caves on cartoons," by Eric Moskowitz

But NYU is a private university, not a newspaper or a government agency. There are no trade-offs here. It is an enclave, a fortress — a sanctuary of intellectual freedom unbeholden to any intellectual hegemony (or should be). If you are a prospective student and you think you will study at this university (or any other for that matter) and not be offended by anything, you’ve got another thing coming. As Greg Lukianoff, a panelist and the president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education said, “No one has a right to not be offended.”

·    ·    ·

New York Post, April 2, "NYU Knuckles"

As the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education noted, NYU's decision is "both chilling and absurd. The fact that expression might provoke a strong reaction is a reason to protect it—not an excuse to punish it."

More media coverage at thefire.org »
RECENT POSTS TO THE TORCH

April 19, "NKU Punishes Vigilante Censorship, but Its Speech Code Remains," Samantha Harris

April 18, "FIRE Asks NYU to Repudiate its Censorship of the Mohammed Cartoons," Greg Lukianoff

April 18, "Thought Reform Guide Reviewed by National Review Online," Robert Shibley

April 17, "The Media Condemns Censorship at NKU," Sean Clark

April 17, "‘Misplaced Political Correctness’," Charles Mitchell

Read The Torch at thefire.org »

UPCOMING EVENTS

April 22, 2006: Conference at the University of Southern California’s Annenberg School of Communications, Los Angeles: “The Politically and Culturally One-Sided Campus: Causes, Consequences, and Remedies.” Hosted by the California Association of Scholars, the conference is cosponsored by FIRE, NAS, CAS, Pacific Legal Foundation, Intercollegiate Studies Institute, Pacific Research Institute, and American Council of Trustees and Alumni. FIRE Chairman Alan Charles Kors will deliver the keynote address. Panels will discuss the nature and causes of the decline in intellectual quality and openness to ideas caused by politicization of the campuses and educational faddism; the effects of this problem on teaching and learning; and proposed remedies to this problem. For more information on the program and registration, please contact CAS Executive Director Rick White. (Kors)

April 25, 2006: Panel discussion at the University of Chicago, Kent Chemical Laboratory Building, room 107, at 7 p.m. (CT). Topic: “Unveiling the Danish Cartoons: A Discussion of Free Speech and World Reaction.” Panel includes Yaron Brook of the Ayn Rand Institute and Tom Flynn of Free Inquiry magazine.  (Lukianoff)

April 29, 2006: Radio interview on The Lowman Henry Show, WHYL 960 AM (Carlisle, Pa.), 9 a.m. (ET). Topic: free speech in academia. (Lukianoff)

More upcoming events at thefire.org »
About This Newsletter

This newsletter may be redistributed in its entirety. If you would like to subscribe to receive future newsletters, please sign up here.

Please direct any comments or questions concerning this newsletter to: subscriptions@thefire.org.

Copyright © 2006, Foundation for Individual Rights in Education
Donate Now · Privacy Policy


Click here if you do not want to receive further emails.

No comments:

Post a Comment